Rental Yield vs EMI: The "Buy vs Rent" Final Verdict

The Great Indian Obsession

In India, buying a house is not a financial decision. It is an Emotional Milestone.

• •Parents: "Beta, stop paying rent. It is dead money. Buy a house."
• •Society: "You are 30 and still renting? Settle down."
• •Bank: "Your pre-approved Home Loan is ready!"

But let's pause the emotion and look at the Math. In 2026, the gap between Rental Yield and Home Loan Interest has never been wider. Buying a house in a top-tier city (Mumbai, Bangalore, Gurgaon) is often financial suicide for your net worth.

In this deep dive, we will use cold, hard numbers to prove why Renting is Smarter than Buying for 90% of urban Indians.

---

Part 1: The Core Math (2.5% vs 8.5%)

To understand why buying is expensive, you need to understand two numbers.

1. Rental Yield (What you Earn/Save)

Rental Yield is the annual rent you receive (or save) divided by the property value.

• •Bangalore/Mumbai: A flat costing ₹2 Crore typically rents for ₹50,000/month.
• •Annual Rent = ₹6 Lakhs.
• •Yield = (6L / 2Cr) * 100 = 3.0%. (In reality, it's often 2-2.5% after maintenance).

2. Cost of Capital (What you Pay)

Home Loan Interest is what you pay the bank to own that asset.

• •Current Rate: 8.5% - 9.0%.

The Gap

You are borrowing money at 8.5% to buy an asset that yields 2.5%. You are legally losing 6% every single year on the face value of the asset. In any other business, this would be called a "Bankruptcy Model". In real estate, we call it "Investment".

---

Part 2: Scenario Analysis (The ₹2 Crore Flat)

Let's look at a realistic scenario for a techie in Bangalore or a finance professional in Mumbai.

The Asset: A 3BHK Apartment in a good society. Price: ₹2,00,00,000 (2 Crores).

Option A: Buying (The "Owner" Life)

• •Down Payment (20%): ₹40 Lakhs (Gone from your savings).
• •Loan Amount: ₹1.6 Crores.
• •Tenure: 20 Years.
• •Interest Rate: 8.5%.
• •EMI: ₹1,38,854 per month.
• •Maintenance + Tax: ~₹8,000/month.
• •Total Monthly Outflow: ~₹1.47 Lakhs.

Option B: Renting (The "Tenant" Life)

• •Rent: ₹50,000 per month.
• •Maintenance: (Usually included or ₹5k extra).
• •Total Monthly Outflow: ~₹55,000.

The Difference

• •BUYING Cost: ₹1.47 Lakhs
• •RENTING Cost: ₹0.55 Lakhs
• •Monthly Savings: ₹92,000

The Argument: "But Rent is throwaway money!" The Rebuttal: "In your EMI of ₹1.38L, for the first 5 years, almost ₹1.10L is purely INTEREST. That is also throwaway money paid to the bank!"

---

Part 3: The Opportunity Cost (The Wealth Killer)

What if you were the "Smart Tenant"? You rent the same house for ₹50k. You take the ₹92,000 difference and invest it in a simple Nifty 50 Index Fund (SIP).

After 20 Years:

1. •The Buyer: Has a paid-off house. Value (assuming 4% appreciation): ~₹4.4 Crores.
2. •The Renter:
   • •SIP Investment: ₹92k/month for 20 years.
   • •Returns (conservative 12%): ₹9.1 Crores.

Result: The Renter can buy TWO such houses with cash and still have money left over. This highlights the power of compounding liquid equity vs illiquid real estate.

---

Part 4: The Counter-Arguments (Nuance)

Real Estate agents will hate the above calculation. Let's address their points.

1. "But Property prices will double in 5 years!"

Fact Check: In the last 10 years (2015-2025), residential real estate in metros has grown at 3-5% CAGR (barely beating inflation). Commercial real estate appreciates. Land appreciates. Apartments depreciate (the building gets old), only the undivided share of land appreciates slowly.

2. "Rent will increase every year!"

True. Rent increases by 5-8%. But your EMI is constant? No.

• •Home ownership costs also increase (Maintenance, Painting, Plumbing, Property Tax).
• •Even with increasing rent, the "SIP Gap" is so massive in the early years that the Renter wins significantly.

3. "Emotional Security? Moving houses is a pain."

Valid. This is the only reason to buy. If you have elderly parents or school-going kids and cannot handle the hassle of shifting every 11/22 months, then BUY.

• •But admit it is a Consumption Cost, not an Investment. You are paying a "Peace of Mind Premium".

---

Part 5: "The 30X Rule" (When to Buy?)

If you really want to buy, use this framework to ensure you aren't overpaying.

The Rule:

Do not buy a house if the Price is > 30X Annual Rent.

Example:

• •You like a flat. Ask the broker: "What is the rent for this?"
• •Broker: "Sir, ₹40,000 per month."
• •Annual Rent = ₹4.8 Lakhs.
• •Max Buy Price = 4.8L * 30 = ₹1.44 Crores.
• •If the builder is asking ₹2.5 Crores for it, WALK AWAY. It is mathematically overvalued.

Why 30X? 30X Annual Rent implies a rental yield of ~3.3%, which is close to fair value when adjusted for tax benefits and appreciation. Anything above 30X is a bubble.

---

Conclusion: Don't Buy the Hype

The "Indian Dream" of buying a house was created when Housing Loans were cheap and property appreciation was high (2000-2010). The math has changed in 2026.

My Verdict:

• •Early Career (20s): RENT. Invest the surplus in Equity. Build a portfolio. Be mobile.
• •Mid Career (30s): RENT. unless you settle in one city permanently.
• •Wealth Stage (40s): BUY (only for self-use), paying a large down payment (40-50%) to keep EMI low.

Remember: Rich people own Assets (Businesses/Stocks). Middle-class people own Liabilities (Homes) thinking they are Assets.